Table 2

Comparison of diagnostic methods of bile acid diarrhoea (BAD)

Diagnostic methodFavourable pointsLimitations
75SeHCATWell established
Predicts response to treatment
Involves radiation
Limited availability in certain countries for example, unavailable in USA
C4No radiation
Simple
Diurnal variation
Fasting sample
Not widely available (in the UK as a research tool)
FGF19No radiation
Simple
Commercial assay available
Diurnal variation
Requires further validation
Faecal bile acids/faecal metabolomicsNo radiationCumbersome
48 hours sample collection versus spot test
Not widely available
Poor patient compliance
UrineEasy collectionExperimental
Not widely available
Therapeutic trialEasily availableUnreliable
Poor response does not exclude diagnosis of BAD
Not cost-effective
Delays diagnosis and affects patients quality of life.
  • FGF19, fibroblast growth factor 19 .