Colorectal surgery | Gervaz et al46 2003 | Retrospective analysis of 72 colorectal adenocarcinoma operations between 1976 and 2001 on cirrhosis patients. | Post-operative death—13% Risk factors predictive of postoperative mortality include elevated bilirubin (p=0.01) and prolonged prothrombin time (p=0.009). CTP-A patients had significantly better survival rates than combined group of CTP-B and C patients (p=0.008)
|
Csikesz et al10 2009 | Retrospective analysis of national database between 1998 and 2005; 22 569 patients with cirrhosis (of whom 4214 had portal hypertension) | Higher mortality for patients undergoing colectomy compared with controls (HR 3.7, 95% CI 2.6 to 5.2) Presence of portal hypertension confers even higher risk (HR 14.3, 95% CI 9.7 to 21.0)
|
Nguyen et al39 2009 | Population based study (1998–2005) identifying 4042 patients | Patients with cirrhosis and cirrhosis with portal hypertension had higher in-hospital mortality in comparison to patients without cirrhosis (14% and 29% vs 5%, respectively, p<0.0001) Approximately four-fold higher rate of in-hospital mortality for emergency and urgent procedures in comparison to elective procedures in liver cirrhosis patients Higher mortality rate of cirrhotic patients with portal hypertension undergoing surgery (HR: 5.8; 95% CI 4.9 to 7.6). Independent risk factors for mortality were cirrhosis, portal hypertension, old age, colectomy and comorbidities which included cardiovascular disease, chronic kidney disease, paraplegia and malnutrition.
|
Ghaferi et al47 2010 | Prospective, clinical database between 2005 and 2007 identifying 1565 patients with chronic liver disease undergoing colorectal resections | Chronic liver disease patients were identified using clinical characteristic: ascites, oesophageal varices or total bilirubin >34 umol/L. 6.5-fold increased risk of mortality following colorectal operations in chronic liver disease patients. MELD score >15 associated with higher rates of mortality and complications (Ascites, infection, bleeding anastomotic leaks and stoma issues including leaks, difficulty closing and peristomal variceal bleeding). |
Montomoli et al87 2013 | Population-based study between 1996 and 2009 identifying 39 840 patients undergoing colorectal surgery with 158 (0.4%) having cirrhosis | |
Lee et al48 2017 | Retrospective analysis of 161 cirrhosis patient undergoing surgery for colorectal cancer (CRC) | |
Lee et al88 2018 | Retrospective, observational, population-based study between 2005 and 2014 identifying 7463 patients with CRC who underwent colorectal surgery. | Increased risk of in-hospital mortality (adjusted OR 2.05, p<0.001) No significant increase in postoperative complications (adjusted OR 0.91, p=0.192)
|
Cheng et al45 2021 | Meta-analysis identifying 2485 patients from 5 studies | Cirrhotic group experienced more major complications (OR 5.15; p=0.005), higher rates of return to theatre (OR: 2.04; p=0.03), higher short-term mortality (OR: 2.8; p<0.00001) and shorter survival (HR 2.96, p<0.00001)
|
Peptic ulcer disease | Lehnert and Herfarth64 1993 | Retrospective analysis (1972–1991), 69 patients undergoing surgery (90%—emergency) for gastroduodenal disease | |
Gastric cancer surgery | Isozaki et al65 1997 | Retrospective analysis of 39 patients with liver cirrhosis undergoing curative surgery for gastric cancer between 1978 and 1994 | |
Guo et al66 2014 | Retrospective analysis of 58 patients with cirrhosis undergoing radical gastrectomy between 2001 and 2012. | Forty-four patients received subtotal gastrectomy and 14 received total gastrectomy accompanied by D1 (26 patients) or D2 (32 patients) lymphadenectomy. Severe postoperative complications occurred in 58.6% of patients and occurred more frequently in CTP-B (p=0.03) or if underwent D2 lymphadenectomy (p=0.015). Postoperative mortality occurred more frequently in CTP-B patients (p=0.033). 100% mortality was experienced in CTP-C.
|
Oesophageal surgery | Valmasoni et al89 2017 | Retrospective analysis of oesophageal cancer database identifying 3445 oesophageal cancer patients, 73 with cirrhosis undergoing surgery. | Cirrhosis patients experienced more respiratory events (p=0.013), infections (p=0.005) and severe anastomotic complications (p=0.046) MELD >9 associated with decreased 5 year survival (p=0.004) and MELD score or nine or lower showed outcomes similar to that of non-cirrhotic patients.
|
Cheng et al90 2020 | Retrospective, propensity-matched study (cirrhotic (n=50) and non-cirrhotic patients (n=100)) | Patients with cirrhosis experience higher rates of postoperative complications including postoperative pneumonia (22 vs 9%, p=0.027), pleural effusion (38 vs 20%, p=0.018), chylothorax (10 vs 1%, p=0.016) and had longer intensive care unit (ICU) stay (mean: 6.10 vs 2.58 days, p=0.002) compared with controls
|
Schizas et al68 2020 | Meta-analysis of 12 observational studies including 1938 patients (238 with cirrhosis) | 30-day mortality higher in cirrhosis (OR 3.04, 95% CI 1.71 to 5.39) although this was not observed at 90 days (OR 2.84, 95% CI 0.94 to 8.93) or long term (mean follow up - 24-months) (OR 1.70, 95% CI 0.53 to 5.51). Anastomotic leak occurred at a higher rate in patients with cirrhosis (OR 2.81, 95% CI 1.05 to 7.49). CTP-A patients were associated with a significantly lower 30-day mortality compared with CTP-B (OR 0.14, 95% CI 0.04 to 0.54).
|
Bariatric surgery | Lee et al91 2021 | Retrospective, 1:1 propensity-matched case control study of 957 patients with and without cirrhosis undergoing bariatric surgery. | No difference in mortality (OR 1.73; p=0.33) Comparing decompensated (n=117) and compensated (n=957) cirrhosis, increased mortality was observed (7.69 vs 0.94%, p<0.001).
|
| Mavilia et al92 2020 | Retrospective study of 20 096 chronic liver disease (using ICD coding) patients undergoing bariatric surgery | Chronic liver disease patients experience high inpatient mortality (adjusted OR 1.47, 95% CI 1.24 to 1.73) but significantly less surgical revision, improper wound healing and postoperative infection following bariatric surgery |
| Agarwal et al71 2021 | Systematic review and meta-analysis including 18 studies and 471 patients with obesity and liver cirrhosis undergoing bariatric surgery (mainly LSG and RYGB) | 397/423 patients with defined CTP class were CTP-A The weighted pooled proportion of overall complications was 22.14% and all-cause 90-day mortality was 0%. Significant increase in postoperative complications (p<0.001) but no difference in all-cause 90-day mortality (p=0.1165) compared with controls.
|
Appendectomy | Rashid et al73 2022 | Meta-analysis of 923 patients with cirrhosis undergoing appendectomy | 30-day mortality 9% vs 0.3% in cirrhosis and non-cirrhosis patients, respectively. Laparoscopic appendectomy appeared safer with a mortality of 0.5% in comparison to open appendectomy with mortality of 3.2%)
|
Umbilical hernia | Snitkjær et al50 2022 | Systematic review of 13 prospective, 10 retrospective studies including 3229 patients | Evidence was graded as very low quality for all outcomes. Mortality quoted to be 6% (n=191). Patients with cirrhosis are eight times more like to die after surgery compared with patients without cirrhosis
|
| De Goede et al52 2021 | Randomised controlled trial (CRUCIAL trial) with 2 years of follow-up recruiting 34 patients with umbilical hernia in liver cirrhosis and ascites | Randomised controlled trial (16—elective repair, 18—conservative management) After 24 months, 8 (50%) assigned to elective repair, in comparison to 14 (77.8%) assigned to conservative treatment had no significant difference in morbidity.
|
| Grey et al93 2008 | Retrospective analysis of 1421 cases, 127 (8.9%) cirrhotics | Elective repair in cirrhosis is associated with similar outcomes in patients without cirrhosis. Cirrhotic patients were more likely to undergo emergency repair (26% vs 4.8%; p<0.0001), concomitant bowel resection (8.8% vs 0.8%; p<0.0001), return to theatre (7.9% vs 2.5%, p=0.0006) and increased length of stay (4 vs 2 days; p=0.01)
|
Eker et al94 2011 | Prospective study | In total, 30 patients (6 CTP-A, 19 CTP-B and 5 CTP-C) with a median MELD score was 12 (IQR 8–16). Elective umbilical hernia repair is safe with no post-operative intensive care admissions and only 2 of 30 patients died; neither of deaths were attributable to umbilical hernia repair.
|
Carbonell et al95 2005 | Nationwide retrospective cohort study 32 033 patients (30, 836 non-cirrhotic and 1197 cirrhotics) | Cirrhotics had a higher age distribution (p<0.0001) underwent ICU admission more commonly (15.9% vs 6%; p<0.0001), had a longer length of stay (5.4 vs 3.7 days), and higher morbidity (16.5% vs 13.8%; p=0.008), and mortality (2.5% vs 0.2%; p<0.0001) compared with non-cirrhotics. Mortality was seven-fold higher in patients undergoing emergency repair (3.8% vs 0.5%; p<0.0001)
|
Marsman et al96 2007 | Retrospective study between 1990 and 2004 34 cirrhosis patients | Elective hernia repair was successful in 12 out of 17 patients without complications and recurrence. 3/17 wound related problems and 4/17 had recurrence. Conservative management was only successful in 23%; 10/13 attended hospitals for incarceration of which 6 required emergency hernia repairs. Two patients managed conservatively died from complications of umbilical hernia.
|
Pinheiro et al97 2020 | Prospective cohort study 246 patients with cirrhosis | A total of 246 patients (57 underwent elective hernia repair and 189 who opted for ‘wait and see’ approach) were included in the study. Of the latter, 43 (22.7%) patients required emergency hernia repair due to complications such as ascites leakage due to skin rupture in hernia site (n=28), incarceration (n=7), small bowel strangulation (n=5), and extensive skin necrosis or ulceration (n=3). MELD score >11 (HR 7.8; p=0.011) and emergency hernia repair (HR 5.35; p=0.005) were identified as risk factors for 30-day mortality.
|
Inguinal hernia | Oh et al98 2011 | Retrospective study over 10-year period 780 patients having inguinal hernia repair. 129 patients with cirrhosis | Morbidity (9.1–16.7%) is not significantly higher than patients without cirrhosis Overall mortality ranging from <1% to 2.7% Cumulative recurrence rates were not significantly different between cirrhosis and non-cirrhosis group (p=0.87)
|
Patti et al99 2008 | Prospective evaluation of QOL by questionnaire including 32 patients. | |
Cardiovascular | Chou et al54 2017 | Nationwide, population-based study from Taiwan between 1997 and 2001 including 1030 Liver patients and 1040 matched controls without cirrhosis. | |
Hayashida et al55 2004 | Retrospective study between 1989 and 2003 of 18 patients with cirrhosis undergoing cardiac operations | Overall postoperative mortality—17% CTP-A—no increased mortality when undergoing elective cardiac surgery CTP-B and C—mortality rate 50%–100% after cardiopulmonary bypass
|
Jacob et al100 2015 | Systematic review (19 studies) of short-term and overall mortality in patients with liver cirrhosis classified by CTP score undergoing cardiac surgery. | CTP score reporting 30-day mortality noted to be 9%, 37% and 52% for CTP class A, B and C, respectively. One-year mortality was reported to be 27.2%, 66.2% and 78.9%, respectively, for CTP class A, B and C, respectively.
|
Araujo et al56 2017 | Retrospective, propensity-matched, case–control study of 1197 patients with liver dysfunction undergoing cardiac surgery (n=755 CABG, n=442 valve surgery) | Increased mortality was observed for both CABG (OR 5.19, p<0.0001) and valve surgery (OR 7.49, p<0.0001) in comparison to controls. Higher rates of complications (bleeding, respiratory, renal, infections) in patients with liver dysfunction and CABG.
|
| Hseih et al57 2015 | Meta-analysis (22 studies, 939 patients—CABG, valve surgery and cardiopulmonary bypass) | Nineteen of the studies evaluated mortality with 354 patients in CTP-A, 205 in CTP-B and 33 in CTP-C. Mean mortality rates were 20.58%, 43.58% and 56.48% for patients in class A, B and C, respectively (p<0.01 for comparisons between each class). Major postoperative morbidity with rates up to 60%, 100% and 100% for CTP-A, B and C, respectively.
|
Steffen et al53 2017 | Retrospective, propensity-matched study between 1998 and 2011 identifying 2769 patients with cirrhosis undergoing surgical aortic valve replacement | Aortic valve surgery in-hospital mortality was 16 vs 5% in controls (OR 3.6, p<0.0001) and greater rate of complications (55% vs 45% for controls). Risk factors of mortality included congestive cardiac failure, fluid and electrolyte disturbances, pulmonary circulation disorder and weight loss.
|
AAA repair | Marrocco-Trischitta et al63 2011 | Retrospective, single centre study between 2001 and 2006 identifying 24 patients with Liver cirrhosis undergoing elective open repair of infrarenal AAA. | |
Elective Hip and knee arthroplasty | Cohen et al74 2005 | Retrospective analysis of outcomes of primary total hip arthroplasty and total knee arthroplasty in cirrhotic patients. | Complication rates, decompensation and/or death in up to 80% of cirrhosis patients after emergency THA due to a fracture. Primary THA or TKA can be safely performed electively in CTP-A and CTP-B patients
|
| Bell et al101 2020 | Retrospective study identifying 18 129 cirrhotic patients undergoing TKA and compared with control of 1716439 TKA patients. | Cirrhosis was associated with increased rate of major complications (3.7% vs 2.3%; OR 1.23, 95% CI 1.13 to 1.33; p<0.001) Higher risk of periprosthetic joint infection compared with controls, minor medical complications (13.5% vs 7.4%; OR 1.52, 95% CI 1.45 to 1.59, p<0.001), transfusion (2.8% vs 1.4%; OR 1.66, 95% CI 1.51 to 1.81, p<0.001), encephalopathy (1.0% vs 0.2%; OR 3.00, 95% CI 2.55 to 3.51, p<0.001), DIC (<0.001) within 90 days Alcohol and viral aetiologies were associated with increased rate of major complications.
|
| Onochie et al78 2019 | Systematic review identifying eight studies on 28514 THA’s | Increased postoperative infection rates of 0.5% (p<0.001) and perioperative mortality of 4.1% (p<0.001). Frequent need for revision surgery at 4% (p<0.001). Aetiology of need for revision surgery included periprosthetic infection (70%), aseptic loosening (13%), instability (13%), periprosthetic fracture (2%) and linear wear (2%).
|