Physician gender and the physician-patient relationship: Recent evidence and relevant questions

https://doi.org/10.1016/0277-9536(85)90189-3Get rights and content

Abstract

Despite criticisms of the quality of health care for women and considerable research on sex differences in illness behavior and utilization of health services, little research has addressed the potential impact of physician gender on the physician-patient relationship and its outcomes. With the entry of more women into the medical profession, opportunities to investigate effects of physician gender will increase. A theoretical rationale for expecting physician gender to affect the key dimensions of the interactive physician-patient relationship (communication of information, affective tone, negotiative quality) and its outcomes (satisfaction, compliance, health status) is presented. Physician gender might impact on the relationship through three mechanisms: sex differences among physicians, particularly with respect to sex-role attitudes; patients' different expectations of male and female physicians; or increased status congruence between physician and patient in same-sex, as compared to opposite-sex, physician-patient dyads. Recent research related to these topics is discussed and found to support the plausibility of these mechanisms of potential gender effects. Some methodological suggestions for future research are presented, including the suggestion that future research identify specific conditions under which physician gender effects might be more salient.

References (67)

  • J. Leeson et al.

    Women and Medicine

    (1978)
  • C.S. Weisman et al.

    Male and female physician career patterns: specialty choices and graduate training

    J. med. Educ.

    (1980)
  • D.M. Burkons et al.

    Is the obstetrician-gynecologist a specialist or primary physician to women?

    Am. J. Obstet. Gynec.

    (1975)
  • J. Gray

    The effect of the doctor's sex on the doctor-patient relationship

    Jl R. Coll. gen. Pract.

    (1982)
  • S.W. Bloom et al.

    Patient–practitioner relationships

  • R.C. Wasserman et al.

    Systematic analysis of clinician–patient interactions: a critique of recent approaches with suggestions for future research

    Med. Care

    (1983)
  • Z. Ben-Sira

    The function of the professional's affective behavior in client satisfaction: a revised approach to social interaction theory

    J. Hlth soc. Behav.

    (1976)
  • M.R. DiMatteo et al.

    Achieving Patient Compliance: The Psychology of the Medical Practitioner's Role

    (1982)
  • W.T. Anderson et al.

    The physician–patient encounter: a process of reality negotiation

  • A. Lazare et al.

    Studies on a negotiated approach to patienthood

  • J.H. Scanzoni

    Sex Roles, Life Styles, and Childbearing

    (1975)
  • C.A. Nathanson

    Illness and the feminine role: a theoretical view

    Soc. Sci. Med.

    (1975)
  • C.A. Nathanson

    Women and health: the social dimensions of biomedical data

  • T. Parsons

    The Social System

    (1951)
  • J.E. Ware et al.

    Dimensions of patient attitudes regarding doctors and medical care services

    Med. Care

    (1975)
  • A. Segall et al.

    Patient evaluation of physician role performance

    Soc. Sci. Med.

    (1980)
  • E. Friedson

    Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of Applied Knowledge

    (1970)
  • T.S. Szasz et al.

    A contribution to the philosophy of medicine: the basic models of the doctor–patient relationship

    Am. med. Ass. Archs intern. Med.

    (1956)
  • D.H. Funkenstein

    Medical Students, Medical Schools and Society During Five Eras: Factors Affecting the Career Choices of Physicians 1958–1976

    (1978)
  • L.K. Cartwright

    Personality differences in male and female medical students

    Psychol. Med.

    (1972)
  • L.K. Cartwright

    Personality changes in a sample of women physicians

    J. med. Educ.

    (1977)
  • J. Leserman

    Men and Women in Medical School: How They Change and How They Compare

    (1981)
  • M. Heins et al.

    Attitudes of women and men physicians

    Am. J. publ. Hlth

    (1979)
  • Cited by (151)

    • Factors and scenarios influencing Arab Americans’ preference for male versus female physicians

      2022, Journal of the National Medical Association
      Citation Excerpt :

      Some studies have shown that characteristics like humaneness and comprehensiveness were top priorities when looking for a physician, while technical competence was lower in priority, regardless of gender8. There is also evidence that patients hold different expectations for male and female physicians and that same-sex physician-patient interactions may have more effective communication and stronger connections than opposite-sex interactions9. This idea is important to explore as some studies show that the preference of one gender over another can delay necessary procedures and represent a barrier for screening.

    • The effect of physician self-disclosure on patient self-disclosure and patient perceptions of the physician

      2021, Patient Education and Counseling
      Citation Excerpt :

      Male physicians who self-disclose are perceived as more competent than female physicians who self-disclose. A study by Weisman [40] stated that studies of patient satisfaction with care received (regardless of the gender of the physician) show that a major dimension of patient satisfaction corresponds to this interpersonal aspect of medical care, also defined as the "affective quality". Assuming the interpersonal dimension is indeed a major factor determining patients’ satisfaction with medical care, and assuming women physicians are perceived by patients as more likely to excel at this dimension of care (such as empathy like mentioned above), one would expect patients to prefer female to male physicians.

    • Detached concern?: Emotional socialization in twenty-first century medical education

      2016, Social Science and Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      Sociologists also often focus on the consequences of these different interpretations, i.e., bias in how women are evaluated. For example, recent sociological studies demonstrate that women professors face bias in their student evaluations (both formal and informal) (Sprague and Massoni, 2005; Hirshfield, 2014), women leaders are constrained in terms of their emotional expression (Ridgeway and Johnson, 1990; Rogalin and Hirshfield, 2013), and women doctors are expected to be more expressive than men doctors (Weisman and Teitelbaum, 1985). The latter (fairly dated) finding, in particular, is ripe for further investigation by sociologists of medical education.

    • Patient and Staff Voices in Primary Care: Learning from Dr Ockrim and Her Glasgow Medical Practice

      2023, Patient and Staff Voices in Primary Care: Learning from Dr Ockrim and Her Glasgow Medical Practice
    View all citing articles on Scopus

    The authors wish to acknowledge the helpful comments of Dr Constance Nathanson, Dr Margaret Ensminger and two anonymous reviewers of an earlier version of this paper.

    View full text