Elsevier

Surgery

Volume 118, Issue 4, October 1995, Pages 599-607
Surgery

Comparison of the costs associated with medical and surgical treatment of obesity1

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0039-6060(05)80024-8Get rights and content

Background. We compared the long-term costs and outcomes of gastric bypass versus medical therapy (very low-calorie diet plus weekly behavioral modification) for obese patients.

Methods. A successful outcome was defined as the loss of at least one third of excess weight that was maintained for the duration of the study. A minimal cost was assigned: $3000 for medical and $24,000 for surgical treatment. A cost per pound of weight lost for all patients successfully monitored was calculated. The Federal Trade Commission recently asked all weight loss programs to report this cost for patients at least 2 years after therapy.

Results. A total of 201 patients entered surgical and 161 entered medical therapy. The surgical group was initially heavier (mean body mass index [kg/m2] ±SE=49.3±0.6 versus 41.2±0.7, p<0.01), but each group's lowest mean body mass index was similar (31.8 versus 32.1, respectively). A significantly higher percentage of patients in the surgical versus the medical group were still successful at year 5: 89% versus 21%. The cost per pound lost for medical therapy exceeded the cost of surgical therapy in the sixth posttreatment year (both more than $250/pound).

Conclusions. Surgical treatment appears to be more cost-effective at producing and maintaining weight loss. It is imperative that long-term follow-up studies be funded to definitely establish this finding.

References (22)

  • MartinLF et al.

    Preoperative insurance status influenced postoperative complication rates for gastric bypass

    Am J Surg

    (1991)
  • PolitserP

    US employers: the new pioneers of health care cost containment

    ACS Bulletin

    (1991)
  • Lauve RM, Martin LF. What surgeons need to know about managed care and outcomes research. Am J Surg (in...
  • Rating the diets

    Consumer Reports

    (1993)
  • BrayGA

    Use and abuse of appetite-suppressant drugs in the treatment of obesity

    Ann Intern Med

    (1993)
  • WaddenTA et al.

    Obesity

  • GravesHA

    Clinical benchmark for gastric stapling procedures

    Obes Surg

    (1994)
  • LiddleRA et al.

    Gallstone formation during weight reduction dieting

    Arch Intern Med

    (1989)
  • 1983 Metropolitan height and weight tables

    Stat Bulletin Metrop Life Insur Co

    (1984)
  • ReinholdRB

    Critical analysis of long-term weight loss following gastric bypass

    Surg Gynecol Obstet

    (1982)
  • Cited by (90)

    • 75 years of the Central Surgical Association: The last quarter century

      2018, Surgery (United States)
      Citation Excerpt :

      Barkun et al17 from Montreal revealed a 40% increase in costs of laparoscopic inguinal herniorrhaphy versus open repair; however, postoperative improvement in pain and quality of life might potentially balance the increased cost. Martin et al18 reported that surgical treatment was more cost-effective than medical management at producing and maintaining weight loss; however, they warned “it is imperative that long-term follow-up studies be funded to definitely establish this finding.” Knechtle et al19 from the University of Wisconsin (Madison) recommended liver transplantation early in the course of primary sclerosing cholangitis in patients with inflammatory bowel disease to avoid the lethal complications of cholangiocarcinoma; however, liver transplantation did not reduce the risk of colon carcinoma.

    • Socioeconomic disparities in eligibility and access to bariatric surgery: a national population-based analysis

      2010, Surgery for Obesity and Related Diseases
      Citation Excerpt :

      A widening body of data have now demonstrated the overall cost-effectiveness of bariatric surgery when examined from a system wide or longer term perspective. A 1995 study comparing the costs of gastric bypass versus medical therapy among 362 patients found surgery was associated with a much greater chance of success at 5 years (89% versus 21%) and that, at 6 years, the cost of medical therapy exceeded that of surgery [35]. An Australian study using a modeled lifetime analysis for patients with type 2 diabetes conclusively demonstrated a mean healthcare savings of $2400 and 1.2 additional quality-adjusted life-years per patient [36].

    • Socioeconomic disparities and access to bariatric surgery

      2010, Surgery for Obesity and Related Diseases
    • The Effect of a Low-Carbohydrate, High-Protein Diet on Post Laparoscopic Gastric Bypass Weight Loss: A Prospective Randomized Trial

      2007, Journal of Surgical Research
      Citation Excerpt :

      Severely obese people rarely lose weight with conventional diet and exercise programs [6]. In this population, surgery is increasingly being viewed as the best intervention for weight loss and maintenance [7–9]. Researchers and surgeons have found bariatric surgery to have significant potential for increased weight loss, maintenance of weight loss, improvement or amelioration of comorbid conditions, improved quality of life, improved productivity, and decreased mortality [9–11].

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    1

    Presented at the Fifty-second Annual Meeting of the Central Surgical Association, Cleveland, Ohio, March 9–11, 1995.

    View full text